Medicare Annual Enrollment ends December 7 — only 27 days left to review your 2026 coverageCall (800) 354-1078

SecureCare65 — Reputation, Reliability, Experience

Carriers

Every Medicare Supplement company we represent

We are independent, which means we are not tied to a single insurer. Below is each carrier we shop on your behalf, with what the company actually is, what it does well, and what to check before you buy.

Figures reviewed for 2026

Shop the whole market

Identical benefits, very different prices

Medigap benefits are standardized by federal law: a Plan G from any of these companies covers exactly the same thing. So the comparison is about premium, rate history, household discounts, and how the carrier handles claims — which is precisely what we evaluate.

Aetna Medicare SupplementMutual of Omaha Medicare SupplementUnited of Omaha Medicare SupplementUnited World Life Medicare SupplementOmaha Supplemental Medicare SupplementCigna Medicare SupplementHealthSpring Medicare SupplementBlue Cross Blue Shield Medicare SupplementAARP Medicare SupplementTransamerica Medicare SupplementMedico Medicare SupplementBankers Fidelity Medicare SupplementBankers Fidelity Assurance Medicare SupplementAtlantic Capital Life Assurance Medicare SupplementBankers Life Medicare SupplementWashington National Medicare SupplementAtlantic Coast Life Medicare SupplementColonial Penn Medicare SupplementCentral States Indemnity Medicare SupplementEquitable Life Medicare SupplementEverest Re Medicare SupplementFederal Life Medicare SupplementGuarantee Trust Life Medicare SupplementHeartland National Medicare SupplementIndividual Assurance Company Medicare SupplementLumico Life Medicare SupplementNational General Medicare SupplementNational Guardian Life Medicare SupplementNew Era Life Medicare SupplementPekin Medicare SupplementPhiladelphia American Medicare SupplementPuritan Life Medicare SupplementShenandoah Medicare SupplementState Mutual Medicare SupplementThrivent Medicare SupplementUnited American Medicare SupplementUnited Home Life Medicare SupplementUnited States Fire Medicare SupplementAmerican Financial Security Medicare SupplementIndependence American Medicare SupplementLifeShield Medicare SupplementINA (Insurance Company of North America) Medicare SupplementACE Medicare SupplementAflac Medicare SupplementLumos Medicare SupplementGerber Life Medicare SupplementWoodmenLife Medicare SupplementPhysicians Mutual Medicare Supplement

Why the cheapest quote is not always the best plan

A low first-year premium means little if the carrier raises rates sharply a few years later. Because Medigap is guaranteed renewable, you are effectively locked into the carrier’s rate history unless you can pass underwriting to move — or you live in a state with a birthday rule. We weigh a company’s pattern of increases as heavily as its current price, and we review your policy against the market every year.

State and coverage guides

Iowa Medicare Supplement PlansMedicare and Home Health Care

Official sources

Check it at the source

Every figure on this page comes from the agencies below. They are the primary record, and none of these links costs you anything.

No cost, no obligation

See what all of these carriers would charge you in 2026

Rates depend on your age, ZIP code, tobacco use, and in some states your health history. Send us a few details and we will put the real numbers side by side.

Start My QuoteCall (800) 354-1078